Wood Fireplace Inserts

Choosing a wood burning fireplace insert

Measure the opening before anything else

This is the gate every insert purchase has to pass, and it is where most of them fail. You need three numbers from your existing masonry firebox: height, width and depth of the opening. Then measure the width at the back as well, because most masonry fireboxes taper inward and the rear width is frequently the dimension that rules a model out. Note the depth from the face to the back wall, and check what the damper does — many installations need the damper plate removed or cut to get the liner through. Every insert publishes a minimum fireplace opening in its manual. Compare your four numbers against that spec before you fall in love with a model.

The liner is not optional, and it is the hidden cost

An insert is not designed to vent into an open masonry flue. Manufacturers and code generally require a continuous stainless steel liner running from the insert all the way to the top of the chimney, usually 6" for the models here, with insulation and a block-off plate. This is the line people forget when they budget, and it is a substantial one — often several thousand dollars once the liner, insulation, cap and labour are counted, and more if the chimney is tall or offset. Get a quote on the liner and the installation at the same time as the appliance, because the two together are the real number. Confirm the requirement with your installer and local code.

Have the chimney inspected first

Before you commit, have a sweep put a camera up the flue. An insert seals the fireplace up, so anything wrong behind it — a cracked clay tile, a deteriorated crown, heavy creosote, a flue that is the wrong size — becomes much harder to reach afterwards. A level 2 inspection is cheap compared with pulling a 400-pound insert back out. It also tells you the true flue height, which determines the liner cost.

Size it to the space, and resist going bigger

Firebox volume is the honest measure of an insert's capacity, and the models here run from 1.6 to 3.0 cubic feet, covering roughly 500 to 3,000 square feet of living space. Match it to the area you actually want to heat rather than the whole house, and account for your layout: open plans move heat, closed floor plans do not, and an insert heats the room it is in far better than the ones around it. An oversized insert is a real problem, not just wasted money — you end up damping it down to stay comfortable, and a wood fire run low burns dirty, builds creosote and glazes the glass.

EPA 2020 is the standard to look for

The EPA's 2020 particulate standard is the current one for wood appliances, and it is a meaningful quality signal rather than a sticker. Certified units burn measurably cleaner — the models here that publish a figure run between 1.26 and 1.7 grams per hour — and they burn cleaner because they extract more heat from the same wood instead of sending it up the flue. Several regions and some local programmes require certified appliances, so check before buying if you are in an air-quality management district.

Catalytic or non-catalytic

A non-catalytic insert uses baffles and secondary air to burn off the smoke. It is simpler, cheaper to maintain, gives a livelier fire, and has nothing to replace. A catalytic model routes exhaust through a coated combustor that burns the smoke at a lower temperature, which buys longer, steadier burns and better efficiency at low output — at the cost of a combustor that needs monitoring and eventual replacement. If you want long overnight burns and steady heat, catalytic earns its keep. If you want simplicity and a bright fire, non-catalytic is the easier appliance to live with.

Get the blower, and know what it does

An insert sits inside masonry, which happily absorbs heat you paid for. A blower moves that heat out into the room and makes a noticeable difference to how the appliance actually performs. Some models here include one; on others it is optional. It needs an electrical outlet at the fireplace, which is worth sorting out during installation rather than afterwards, and it means the fan stops in a power cut — the insert still radiates heat, it just distributes it less well.

Plan for the surround and the hearth

Most inserts need a surround panel to cover the gap between the appliance and the fireplace opening, and they are sized — typically around 29" x 44" or 32" x 50" — so the one you need depends on your opening. Some are trimmable, some are not. There are also hearth extension and clearance requirements in front of the appliance, which your existing hearth may or may not already satisfy. Both are in the manual, and both are easier to solve before the installer arrives.

Wood burning fireplace insert FAQs

What is a wood burning fireplace insert?

It is a sealed, steel or cast iron firebox designed to slide into an existing masonry fireplace, turning an open hearth into a closed, controlled appliance. Air is regulated, the fire burns behind glass, and a stainless liner carries exhaust up the existing chimney. The result behaves like a wood stove but uses the fireplace and chimney you already own, and takes up no floor space.

How much more efficient is an insert than my open fireplace?

Dramatically. An open masonry fireplace typically runs between 5 and 15% efficiency and draws heated household air up the chimney while it burns, which is why a room can feel colder once the fire dies down. A modern sealed insert runs roughly 70 to 80% — two of the models here publish 77%. You are burning the same wood and keeping most of the heat instead of most of the smoke.

Do I need a chimney liner for a wood insert?

In almost every case yes, and you should budget for it from the start. Manufacturers and code generally require a continuous stainless liner from the insert to the top of the chimney, insulated, with a block-off plate at the damper. It is what makes the appliance draft correctly and burn safely, and it is frequently the largest single cost after the insert itself. Confirm the specific requirement with your installer and your local code.

Will an insert fit my fireplace?

Measure before you shop. You need the height, width and depth of the masonry opening, plus the width at the back, because most fireboxes taper and the rear dimension often decides it. Every model publishes a minimum fireplace opening in its manual, and the depth is usually the tightest constraint. Also check the damper, since many installations require the plate to be removed or cut so the liner can pass.

How big an insert do I need?

Go by firebox volume and the published heating area, then temper it with your floor plan. The models here span 1.6 to 3.0 cubic feet and roughly 500 to 3,000 square feet. An open plan distributes heat and a closed one does not, and an insert always heats its own room best. Avoid oversizing: a too-large insert has to be run damped down, which burns dirtier, builds creosote and blackens the glass.

What is the difference between a wood insert and a wood stove?

Mostly where it sits. An insert is built to fit inside an existing masonry fireplace and vent up that chimney with a liner, so it takes no floor space. A freestanding stove sits out in the room on a hearth pad with clearances on every side and needs its own flue, which lets it radiate from all surfaces and often deliver a little more heat. If you already have a fireplace, the insert is almost always the right answer. Some models — the four Buck Stove units here among them — can be installed either way.

Can I put a wood insert into a prefab or zero-clearance fireplace?

Only if both the insert and the fireplace are specifically listed for it, and most are not. A factory-built metal fireplace is a tested assembly, and installing an appliance it was not certified with voids its listing and creates a genuine hazard. Some manufacturers do list particular inserts for particular prefab fireplaces. Check the model's manual and your fireplace's data plate, and have an installer confirm before ordering.

Related collections

• All fireplace inserts
• Wood stoves
• Wood burning fireplaces
• Gas fireplace inserts
• Electric fireplace inserts
• All fireplaces